20 Homemade Pie Filling Recipes

Who doesn’t love pie? It’s undoubtedly one of the most universal desserts, and every type has a unique taste! Plus, it’s the highlight of many holidays; for instance, many people eat pumpkin pie for Christmas or thanksgiving. But you don’t have to eat these pie-filling recipes on a specific day; they are perfect for every occasion.

So are you ready for some tasty pie recipes? Here they are;

Lemon Cream Pie

Lemon adds a zesty taste to every dessert; now, imagine how delicious this lemon cream pie will be. This luscious pie is a no-bake recipe, which makes it super easy to prepare.

You need fresh lemons for this creamy treat because of the lemon juice and zest. Mix with other ingredients, such as sweetened condensed milk and vanilla extract. The sweet, creamy filling pairs well with the graham crackers crust for a crunchy bite.

Finish with a mildly sweet whipped cream topping and serve.

Southern Buttermilk Pie

This southern buttermilk pie features simple ingredients sitting in your pantry right now! It’s a quick, delicious, and easy-to-make dessert that everyone loves.

It has a sour and sweet taste that is so savory that it keeps you coming back for more! The buttermilk mix has a beautiful creamy consistency and a tangy balancing taste. Pair this gooey middle with a flaky crust and an excellent dessert.

Ensure you refrigerate your pie to prevent it from rotting.

Peach Pie

Nothing quite like a beautifully baked peach pie- everything from the juicy cinnamon-spiced peach filling to the buttery crust is perfect!

Peach pie might be a staple dessert for the fall season, but you can enjoy it anytime. To get the appropriate consistency, chop your peaches instead of slicing them. This step will prevent you from having a mushy filling and having a bite with each fork.

The steps may be a bit more than others on the list, but it is worth every bite of this juicy and sweet dessert.

Cheddar Apple Pie

If you love apples, you’ll have no choice but to embrace this apple pie filling recipe. The apple filling is flavored with cinnamon and other warm spices before being baked in a buttery cheddar cheese crust.

This homemade apple pie is nothing short of delicious, but it is easy to bake and beautiful. The golden brown lattice crust adds an appeal that makes you want more after each bite.

Use golden delicious or granny Smith apples for this tasty treat because they don’t cook quickly and hold the flavor properly.

Pumpkin Pie

No list of pie filling recipes is complete without pumpkin pie. It’s one of the most popular pies in the world, and for a good reason- it is quick, easy, and flavorful.

Pumpkin pies have a rich, smooth taste that dances on your taste buds after a bite. The filling is infused with warm spices such as cloves, nutmegs, pumpkin pie spice, ginger, and others. Pour in a bed of flaky, homemade pie crust, and you have a delightful dessert.

Serve a slice with whipped cream as the topping.

Chocolate Pie

Here’s a pie that will satisfy your sweet tooth in minutes. Bursting with chocolate flavor, this moist and tasty treat is perfect for kids and adults.

If you’re in a time crunch and need to prepare this dessert, you can always use a packaged pie crust. First, add the chocolate filling containing unsweetened cocoa powder, vanilla extract, evaporated milk, butter, and other delicious ingredients.

Bake and allow to cool before serving; it will deliver a rich, fudgy consistency. Serve with a scoop of ice cream or whipped cream.

Mango Cream Pie

Mango pie is a tropical twist to the pie game you never saw coming. This pie is everything! It’s easy to prepare, delicious, and perfect for summer and any occasion… What else do you need?!

This light and airy dessert feature a homemade graham cracker crust topped with a delicious fresh mango filling. It’s naturally sweet and has a luscious consistency.

Each slice is served with a pillowy whipped cream and toasted flaked coconut as the topping. It is delicious!

Key Lime Pie

One thing that sets key lime pie apart from other pies is the flavor- key limes have a slightly bitter and tart flavor. Hence, it’s excellent at balancing the sweet flavors of sugar in several desserts.

This key lime pie is fluffy, light, and incredibly tasty. This refreshing dessert requires yogurt, condensed milk, lime juice, and lime zest. Use a pre-packaged pie crust or make it from scratch; it will taste amazing.

Serve with whipped cream, a meringue topping, and slices of lime as garnish.

Blueberry Cream Cheese Pie

This blueberry cream cheese pie will make your day if you feel like eating a fragrant and juicy dessert. Filled with a mousse-like cheesecake mix, this delicious pie also features graham crackers crust and a vibrant blueberry topping.

This fluffy pie has a light and airy consistency like a no-bake cheesecake. The cake melts in your mouth and tastes incredible; the light pie filling mixed with the jammy blueberry topping is perfect!

You can use frozen blueberries for this dessert.

Oreo Cookie Pie

Oreos are one of the most popular cookies, and for good reasons- they are delicious, creamy, and work well with several desserts. This Oreo cookie cake is perfect for your kid’s party, birthday, valentine’s, and others!

It’s a no-bake recipe that is delicious and easy to make; you need three ingredients- Oreos, butter, and a cool whip. The Oreos are in the crust and filling, so you get a generous amount of creamy and delicious chocolate flavor.

Serve and garnish with an Oreo cookie and crumbs.

Bourbon Sweet Potato Pie

Another festive pie filling recipe that you need to try is this Bourbon sweet potato pie. It’s delicious and has warm spices such as cinnamon and cloves, making it a perfect fall dessert.

Easy to make and full of different complementing flavors, this tasty pie has hints of bourbon and vanilla in the filling. Also, it’s placed in a flaky pie crust before it is baked on medium heat.

Finally, you can serve with a mildly sweet and pillowy marshmallow creme as the topping.

Cherry Pie

Whip up this scrumptious cherry pie in minutes and get a flavorful experience all day. These flaky goodies are a welcoming treat to your taste buds.

Filled with juicy berries, this hand pie has a flaky exterior that works beautifully with the mushy center. In addition to the wonderful taste, these handheld snacks are perfect for picnics, birthdays, and other parties!

Enjoy your favorite beverage!

Coconut Cream Pie

This creamy pie is an irresistible dessert that makes the end of every meal memorable. Bursting with the natural sweetness of coconuts, the filling consists of cornstarch, shredded coconut, canned coconut milk, and other delicious ingredients.

Cook all the ingredients before placing the thick and creamy coconut filling in a pie crust. Allow it to set for at least 24 hours in the refrigerator before it is ready.

Serve with a coconut-infused whipped cream or meringue topping.

French Silk Pie

This French silk pie is a chocolate pie with a smooth and velvety filling that pairs well with an extra flaky crust.

Unlike other chocolate pie recipes, this one uses cooked eggs, making it a bit healthier. Serve with whipped cream and chocolate shavings as garnish.

Chess Pie

This basic pie might seem plain, but it makes up for its taste. It features cornmeal for a nice texture and vanilla for a sweet flavor.

Chess pie is very similar to buttermilk pie, except for a few differences; buttermilk pie doesn’t require cornmeal, and it is flavored with lemon juice and zest. Nevertheless, they are both incredibly delicious pies you will enjoy.

Finish with a light dust of granulated sugar before serving.

Raspberry-Rhubarb Pie

You’ll love this tasty pie filling recipe if you love fresh fruit pies. Made with a delicious combination of raspberry and rhubarb, it’s juicy and sweet.

The flavor of the filling is also enhanced with a splash of orange juice and orange zest for a tangy addition. Paired with a beautiful golden brown lattice crust, it’s an excellent summertime dessert.

Serve it plain or with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

Blackberry Pie

Here’s another pie made with fresh fruits that tastes even better than it looks. Loaded with jammy blackberries, this pie is scrumptious and appropriate for several occasions.

The blackberry filling is flavored with a bit of lemon, almond extract, and warm spices like cinnamon. It’s so yummy! Plus, it’s easy to make- you can use fresh or store-bought berries for this dish.

Pecan Pie

Ditch the pumpkin pie next thanksgiving and whip up this scrumptious pecan pie! This pecan pie is the perfect dessert for quick, flavorful, and easy to prepare.

For this method, you’ll need brown sugar, corn syrup, butter, vanilla, and other ingredients that enhance the taste of pecans. Place the mixture in a homemade pie crust, bake, and cool.

It’s advisable to make pecan pie a day before so it can cool down properly because it is a bit runny when it’s warm.

Peanut Butter Banana Cream Pie

This is the creamiest pie you’ve ever had! Banana has a mildly sweet flavor that pairs nicely with the nutty taste of peanut butter. Hence, you’re in for a treat!

It’s simple to prepare- all you need is a graham crackers pie crust, filling, and whipped cream. The filling features deliciously creamy additions like bananas, French Vanilla Instant Pudding, Sweetened Condensed Milk, Neufchatel Cheese, and others.

Serve with whipped cream and banana slices as the topping.

Banoffee Pie

Whip this easy pie for breakfast, brunch, and any other occasion. It’s an excellent dessert for an impromptu gathering because it takes less than thirty minutes to make.

This specific no-bake recipe is vegan, and it’s utterly delicious! The creamy filling features vegan butter, brown sugar, caramel, bananas, whipped cream, and others. Place the mix in a tasty crust made with digestive biscuits and allow it to cool.

Decorate with whipped cream, banana slices, and some chocolate shavings.

20 pie filling recipes

20 pie filling recipes

Recipe by Brenda

In the mood for a delicious slice of pie? Try one of these incredibly tasty pie filling recipes today!


  • Lemon Cream Pie

  • Southern Buttermilk Pie

  • Peach Pie

  • Cheddar Apple Pie

  • Pumpkin Pie

  • Chocolate Pie

  • Mango Cream Pie

  • Key Lime Pie

  • Blueberry Cream Cheese Pie

  • Oreo Cookie Pie

  • Bourbon Sweet Potato Pie

  • Cherry Pie

  • Coconut Cream Pie

  • French Silk Pie

  • Chess Pie

  • Raspberry-Rhubarb Pie

  • Blackberry Pie

  • Pecan Pie

  • Peanut Butter Banana Cream Pie

  • Banoffee Pie


  • Choose your preferred recipe
  • Organize all the necessary ingredients
  • Prepare a pie filling recipe in an hour or less!
4.2/5 - (6 votes)