14 Best Thanksgiving Potato Recipes

You can never go wrong with mashed, roasted, fried, or boiled potatoes; they always taste amazing. So, expect nothing less from these 14 thanksgiving potato recipes.

Thanksgiving potatoes are the perfect dish because they are versatile and incredibly delicious. Whether you prefer a simple savory dish like garlic mashed potatoes or extra buttery and cheesy potato gratin, you can prepare it! Not to mention, most people love potatoes, even the pickiest eaters.

Plus, if you happen to mess up your thanksgiving side dishes, I promise no one will notice once they try one of these potato recipes;

1. Roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes

This bowl of mashed potatoes is so inviting you wouldn’t be able to resist. It’s creamy, buttery, and insanely flavorful. Also, it’s super easy to make!

Mashed potatoes are great, but the roasted garlic in this recipe elevates the flavor profile by adding a savory, warm taste. You only need simple ingredients- red potatoes, heavy cream, butter, milk, garlic, and others.

Boil and mix all of your ingredients, and if you love garlic flavor, add some cloves alongside some parsley as toppings.

2. Crispy Herb Roasted Potatoes

It doesn’t get easier than these herb-roasted potatoes. A classic that looks and tastes incredible, everyone on your thanksgiving table will be thrilled to have a plate.

These potatoes are roasted to perfection and burst with potato and garlic flavor. But there are other herbs in the mix- rosemary and thyme both prevent the potatoes from tasting too garlicky. Instead, the potatoes are crispy, tender, and aromatic; it’s so inviting!

It’s an incredible side dish that is flavorful and easy to make; what more could you want?

3. Fondant Potatoes

There’s something special about fondant potatoes; is it their soft and fluffy texture or the buttery and savory flavor? I believe it’s both because I always go back for more.

These fondant potatoes are delicious and surprisingly simple to make, perfect for Thanksgiving and Christmas dinners. Thanks to the addition of chicken/vegetarian stock, they are packed with flavor. The insides are soft and fluffy, which complements the crisp exteriors.

Use Maris Pipers potatoes because they are floury and absorb flavor with ease.

4. Cheesy Potato au Gratin

You’ll swoon over potato au gratin if you love cheesy side dishes. Deliciously cheesy and flavorful, this is a simple potato side dish that works with every thanksgiving menu.

Each bite of this tasty dish is a pleasant surprise; the brown and crispy top opens up to a cheesy and creamy middle. Adding pepper and garlic delivers a slightly warm hint to every bite, which is excellent for balancing the creaminess.

It would be best if you had russet potatoes for this delightful dish and other pantry ingredients. Your guests are in for a treat with this dish!

5. Sour Cream & Onion Potato Salad

Do you love onion and sour cream potato chips? You will surely enjoy this savory potato salad if your answer is yes.

This dish has a balanced dose of salty, tangy, and garlicky flavor. Plus, it’s so creamy; you have sour cream and mayonnaise to thank for this. And to top it off, it’s finished with some sour cream & onion chips for extra crunch!

It would help if you had small waxy gold potatoes for the best texture for this recipe.

6. Crispy Parmesan Potato Wedges

Here’s a tasty side dish that captures everyone’s attention from across the room. These crispy potato wedges are delicious and a favorite of many platters.

They are tender on the inside and extra crispy on the outside. Served hot and ready to eat, each potato wedge has a savory parmesan crust as a flavorful finish. Don’t be surprised when you return for seconds, because they’re that good!

Serve with spicy ketchup, Bleu cheese sauce, or cool ranch for a delightful flavor.

7. Potato Broccoli Cakes

Nothing compares to some scrumptious potato broccoli cakes. They’re healthy and, most of all, utterly delicious.

When you talk about a balanced flavor profile, these potato and broccoli cakes should top your list. They have dill and a spicy cashew sauce to go with them. So you get the naturally sweet taste of potatoes and spicy sauce to balance it out.

Pair this with their soft and fluffy texture, and you have a wonderful thanksgiving side dish.

8. Sweet Potato Shepherd’s Pie

You can’t make a list of Thanksgiving potato recipes without this flavorful shepherd’s pie. This is one of the spiciest and savory meals on the menu.

Spicy and savory, sweet potato shepherd’s pie is a classic that needs no introduction. It’s a hearty dish that features a beefy vegetable mixture flavored with beef gravy and other spices. Finally, it is topped with potatoes before baking in the oven.

It’s so easy to make and healthy. Plus, it’s perfect as a main meal and side dish.

9. Duchess Baked Potatoes

Just have a look at how cute and satisfying these swirl tops are. In addition, Duchess baked potatoes are deliciously impressive and excellent as a side dish.

Think of them as the most savory and creamy mashed potatoes you’ve ever had but piped to this beautiful form. Each potato mound has a crispy, buttery exterior that encloses the sweet and creamy center.

Are you salivating already? Good, because that’s how your guests will always feel!

10. Bourbon Sweet Potato Casserole

Add a sweet and savory twist to your thanksgiving menu with this warm meal. It’s similar to your classic sweet potato casserole but topped with bacon pecans.

It features buttery sweet potatoes flavored with warm spices like cinnamon. But elevates it is the perfectly Herby and sweet pecan topping. The combination gives it a balanced flavor that works well with the textures and makes it irresistibly delicious.

Bourbon is added for a welcomed hint of heat; it’s delicious and excellent for everyone, including picky eaters.

11. Golden Potato Cake

These pan-fried potato cakes are just what you need to get the party going. You can whip this handheld treat perfectly fried to a crispy finish in a few minutes.

Made with tasty mashed potatoes, they are delightfully fluffy and soft in the middle. Their dense texture and mild flavor make them excellent for dipping. So, serve with your favorite sauces, chutney, salsa, or creamy dips.

Your guests will love this potato appetizer!

12. Spicy Sweet Potato Hummus

Everyone loves good hummus, and this spicy sweet potato hummus is heaven on a plate. Loaded with sweet potatoes and chickpeas, it’s incredibly flavorful and nutritious.

It’s flavored with olive oil, sea salt, cayenne pepper, garlic, and paprika for that heat. And some lemon juice and lemon zest for a tangy addition; paired with potatoes’ natural sweetness, it’s incredible.

Serve this creamy hummus with some potato chips.

13. Chicken Enchilada Stuffed Sweet Potatoes

Sweet potatoes stuffed with chicken or beef are one of my best dishes to serve for Thanksgiving. Even though there are several recipes online, this chicken enchilada stuffed sweet potatoes are too good to be true.

Made with some chicken breast, cheese, and enchiladas sauce, it packs a lot of flavors and requires minimal effort. Trust me when I say no one at your party can resist this delicious goodness.

For a tasty finish, a tasty finish, top with sour cream, cheddar cheese, scallions, and cilantro.

14. Bourbon Sweet Potato Pie

Here’s another thanksgiving potato recipe that everyone at your table will swoon over. Insanely delicious and simple to make, this bourbon sweet potato pie will be finished in minutes.

It is flavored with cinnamon and nutmeg and has a spicy taste that balances the creamy texture. In addition, the bourbon adds a hint of heat that elevates the overall taste. Meanwhile, brown sugar, vanilla, and the natural sweetness of roasted potatoes are all you need to tie this dish together.

Serve with whipped cream, and enjoy!

14 thanksgiving potato recipes

14 thanksgiving potato recipes

Recipe by Brenda

Potatoes are awesome! Try one or some of these 14 thanksgiving potato recipes and your guests will thank you!


  • Roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes

  • Crispy Herb Roasted Potatoes

  • Fondant Potatoes

  • Cheesy Potato au Gratin

  • Sour Cream & Onion Potato Salad

  • Crispy Parmesan Potato Wedges

  • Potato Broccoli Cakes

  • Sweet Potato Shepherd’s Pie

  • Duchess Baked Potatoes

  • Bourbon Sweet Potato Casserole

  • Golden Potato Cake

  • Spicy Sweet Potato Hummus

  • Chicken Enchilada Stuffed Sweet Potatoes

  • Bourbon Sweet Potato Pie


  • Choose your preferred recipe
  • Organize all the necessary ingredients
  • Whip up a Thanksgiving potato recipe in 30 minutes or less!
4.3/5 - (3 votes)